Our Top Picks
A good murder mystery game turns an ordinary evening into an investigation. The best ones hand you a victim, a stack of evidence and a room full of suspects, then let your group argue its way to an accusation. Some play like a detective’s case file spread across the table, with police reports, photographs and witness statements. Others turn your dining room into the crime scene, with every guest playing a suspect who has something to hide. Both formats come complete in a single box and finish in one sitting.
The five picks below cover both styles. Two come from Hunt A Killer, the best-known name in the genre, and two from Unsolved Case Files. The fifth is a dinner party classic from University Games, where the players themselves are the suspects. Every pick is a standalone case with its own story, evidence and solution, and enough material for a full evening.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Picks
- Hunt A Killer: Death at the Dive Bar — the easiest Hunt A Killer case and the friendliest starting point for new detectives, for 1 to 5 players.
- Hunt A Killer: Body on the Boardwalk — a step up in difficulty: a seaside amusement park, ciphers and decoy clues, for 1 to 5 players.
- Unsolved Case Files: Avery & Zoey Gardner — an active case with a missing twin and a missing detective; the longest session here, at 2 to 6 hours.
- Unsolved Case Files: Jamie Banks — a 1992 high school cold case ruled a suicide, built around proving it was murder.
- Murder Mystery Party: A Taste for Wine & Murder — a hosted dinner party kit for 6 to 8 players, with character booklets, invitations and recipes.
How to Choose
Pick a format first. Case file games, like the Hunt A Killer and Unsolved Case Files picks here, put you in the detective’s chair. Nobody at the table is the killer; the group works together through documents, photos and clues to name a suspect who exists only in the story. They suit couples, families and puzzle fans. Dinner party kits work the other way round: each guest plays a character with secrets, one guest is the murderer, and the host usually plays along too. They take more organising, but give you an event rather than a puzzle session.
Match the player count. The case file games here support 1 to 5 players or an open-ended group, and scale well because everyone shares the same evidence. The dinner party kit needs 6 to 8 players to fill its roster, and falls flat if guests drop out, so choose it only when your guest list is firm.
Check the clock. Death at the Dive Bar runs about 45 to 60 minutes, which suits a weeknight. Body on the Boardwalk takes an hour or more. The Unsolved Case Files games are the long haul: the maker says most teams of two or more need 2 to 6 hours, so plan them for a weekend.
Mind the difficulty and the age guide. Hunt A Killer marks its boxes on a five-step difficulty scale; the two picks here sit at steps 1 and 2, so both welcome newcomers. The case file games are guided for ages 14 and up; the dinner party kit is aimed at adults, 16 and up, with classic whodunit content.
Expect one full play per box. These are story games with a fixed solution, so once your group knows the ending, the surprise is spent. Most players pass a finished case to friends or swap with another group, so treat each box as one big event night.
Hunt A Killer: Death at the Dive Bar
Death at the Dive Bar is the case that introduces most people to boxed mystery games. Nick Webster, owner of the Old Scratch Tavern, fell to his death from the cliff behind his bar. The fall was ruled an accident, but an employee believes it was murder and hires you to prove it. The box gives you forensic files, suspect profiles and evidence tied to a masked figure seen near the scene: your job is to work out who wanted Webster dead.
Hunt A Killer grades this as its easiest case, step 1 on its five-step difficulty scale, and the 45 to 60 minute running time suits a weeknight. A dedicated hints page covers each item in the box, so a stuck group can take a nudge without spoiling the case.
Specs
| Detail | Value |
|---|---|
| Players | 1 to 5 |
| Ages | 14 and up |
| Playing time | 45 to 60 minutes |
| Difficulty | Step 1 of 5 on the maker’s scale |
| Box dimensions | 9.5 x 10.5 x 2 inches |
| Item weight | 1 pound |
| Model number | HAKZEROBD001-C |
See Death at the Dive Bar on Amazon
Hunt A Killer: Body on the Boardwalk
Body on the Boardwalk raises the challenge a notch. Katie Dunn, an employee at a seaside amusement park, is found dead inside a ride, and her boyfriend is quickly named the prime suspect. Your group digs into the park’s secrets, sorts genuine clues from decoys and decides whether the obvious suspect is really the killer.
At step 2 of 5 on the maker’s difficulty scale, this case leans harder on ciphers and puzzles, and most groups should allow an hour or more. It suits 1 to 5 players aged 14 and up, with hints and solutions available for each stage. Choose it if your group finished the Dive Bar case quickly.
Specs
| Detail | Value |
|---|---|
| Players | 1 to 5 |
| Ages | 14 and up |
| Playing time | 1 hour or more |
| Difficulty | Step 2 of 5 on the maker’s scale |
| Box dimensions | 9.5 x 10.5 x 2 inches |
| Item weight | 1.63 pounds |
| Model number | HAKRET2BD002 |
See Body on the Boardwalk on Amazon
Unsolved Case Files: Avery & Zoey Gardner
The Gardner case is the most urgent story in the Unsolved Case Files series, because part of it is still live. In Davenport, Oregon, an intruder broke into a remote lake house where 19-year-old twins Avery and Zoey Gardner were sleeping. Avery was murdered, Zoey was abducted, and the lead detective went missing while following the killer’s trail. The case file, numbered G-668H, asks you to convict the killer and find Zoey before it is too late.
Play is organised around three objectives, each confirmed through an online answer key before you move on. The box includes a lead detective’s notebook plus evidence photos, newspaper articles, phone records, a coroner’s report and a crime scene map, all made to look like genuine case material. There is no fixed player limit, but allow plenty of time: the maker puts most teams at 2 to 6 hours.
Specs
| Detail | Value |
|---|---|
| Players | 1 or more, no set limit |
| Ages | 14 and up |
| Playing time | 2 to 6 hours |
| Objectives | 3 |
| Box dimensions | 13 x 8 x 0.7 inches |
| Item weight | 10.5 ounces |
See the Avery & Zoey Gardner case on Amazon
Unsolved Case Files: Jamie Banks
Jamie Banks reopens a case that was closed decades ago. On November 20, 1992, Jamie, an 18-year-old senior at East Verona High School in Verona, Massachusetts, fell from a sixth-floor window in the school newspaper room. Five people at the school were unaccounted for at the time, yet investigators ruled the death a suicide. Case number B17-11201992 asks you to prove she did not jump, break a key suspect’s alibi and identify the clue that convicts the real killer.
The suspect list gives the case its flavour: a football player Jamie once dated, his cheerleader girlfriend, the guidance counselor who ran the school paper and Jamie’s understudy in the school play. As with the Gardner case, progress runs through three objectives checked against an online answer key. Pick it for secrets and school politics over forensic puzzles.
Specs
| Detail | Value |
|---|---|
| Case number | B17-11201992 |
| Case year | 1992 |
| Setting | Verona, Massachusetts |
| Suspects | 5 |
| Objectives | 3 |
| Package weight | 1.72 pounds |
See the Jamie Banks case on Amazon
Murder Mystery Party: A Taste for Wine & Murder
A Taste for Wine & Murder is the hosted format at its most classic, in print since 1997. The annual wine-tasting festival in California wine country is under way when the body of vineyard owner Barry Underwood is found beneath his wine cellar, six years after he disappeared. Your guests do not examine a case file; they become the suspects, each working from a character booklet.
The kit is built around a real dinner. It includes eight invitations, place cards, character booklets, secret clues, a police report and the author’s solution, plus a party planner with a shopping list, menus and recipes by cookbook author Sandra Gluck. An included CD provides the introduction and solution, so the host can play a suspect too. Choose it when you want the mystery to be the party itself.
Specs
| Detail | Value |
|---|---|
| Players | 6 to 8 |
| Ages | 16 and up |
| Model number | 33202 |
| Box dimensions | 12 x 8 x 4 inches |
| Item weight | 16 ounces |
| Character booklets | 8 |
See A Taste for Wine & Murder on Amazon
Products at a Glance
| Game | Format | Players | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hunt A Killer: Death at the Dive Bar | Case file | 1 to 5 | First-time detectives, weeknights |
| Hunt A Killer: Body on the Boardwalk | Case file | 1 to 5 | Groups wanting more puzzles |
| Unsolved Case Files: Avery & Zoey Gardner | Case file | 1 or more | A long, deep investigation |
| Unsolved Case Files: Jamie Banks | Case file | Solo or group | Story-led cold case fans |
| Murder Mystery Party: A Taste for Wine & Murder | Dinner party kit | 6 to 8 | A hosted evening in character |
FAQ
Can you play these murder mystery games on your own?
Yes. The four case file games work solo because the group is effectively one detective team; a single player can work through the objectives at their own pace. The dinner party kit is the exception: it needs 6 to 8 players to fill every suspect role.
Do you need an internet connection to play?
For the Unsolved Case Files games, yes, at least at checkpoints: each objective is confirmed through an online answer key, which keeps the game spoiler-free. The Hunt A Killer boxes use an online hints page, while the dinner party kit is fully paper and CD based and needs no connection.
Can you replay a murder mystery game once you know the ending?
Not with the same group, because the solution, the culprit and the key clues are fixed. Most groups pass the box on, swap cases, or host the dinner party kit for different guests. Treat each box as one big event night, then trade it.
What is the difference between a case file game and a dinner party kit?
In a case file game, everyone plays detectives and nobody at the table is guilty; you solve the crime by studying documents and evidence. In a dinner party kit, every guest plays a suspect with a character booklet and secrets to protect, one guest is the murderer, and the mystery unfolds through conversation over a meal.
Conclusion
If you are new to the genre, start with Death at the Dive Bar: the shortest, gentlest case here, done in under an hour. Groups who want more bite should move to Body on the Boardwalk; long-session players will get the most from the Gardner and Jamie Banks files. For a full evening with friends in character, A Taste for Wine & Murder remains the dinner party benchmark. Whichever you choose, clear the table, silence the phones and let the argument about the killer begin.
FAQ
Can you play these murder mystery games on your own?
Do you need an internet connection to play?
Can you replay a murder mystery game once you know the ending?
What is the difference between a case file game and a dinner party kit?
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeA Prime membership for ages 18-24 with a trial period. Eligibility is set by Amazon.
See Prime for Young AdultsAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.



